In his senior year at South, Vince was named team MVP and rushed for 1,136 yards on 205 carries. He averaged more than 5 yards per carry throughout his 3 year varsity career and was named to the Academic All-Area Team all four years.

Vince when on to play at Hillsdale College (2005 to 2009) where he had 3,660 career yards on 760 carries with 54 touchdowns which places him third in all-time rushing yardage and second in career scoring.  In his senior year he rushed for 1,444 yards on 291 carries with 25 touchdowns which places him third on Hillsdale’s all-time single season scoring list.  Vince was honorable mention during his sophomore and junior years and first team All-GLIAC as a senior.